( 2nd
Part ) Analysis & answer of
Dr.Zakir Naik's 25 mistake in 5 min
6) Sixth mistake: Jakir says, “Darwin says, He has missing links. That’s he also didn’t believe his theory”.
6) Sixth mistake: Jakir says, “Darwin says, He has missing links. That’s he also didn’t believe his theory”.
The objector Ahmed said, “Darwin had missing links , true but it
does not mean that he didn’t believe it. Rather he gave some ideas about where
the missing links could be found”.
Analysis: An inventor can only believe his theory when he
finds every possible proof in his theory. Darwin didn’t find 100% proof himself,
so how can he believe his theory 100%?
Remember a scientist never say that he is right, because, he knows that
someday his theory may be proved wrong.
Interesting thing is that, not only Darwin but also at
least 480 enlisted scientists or intellectuals are found on net, who didn’t
agree with the theory or spoke against it. Let’s see their names ---
Decision: We can’t say that Jakir
was wrong.
7)
Seventh mistake: Jakir
says, “Previously Church was against science”.
The objector says, “No, Church was never against science”.
Analysis: The way Mr. so – called
ahmed tried to protect Church, it reveals that he came to speak it in favor of
a community. Years after years church acted against science and the invention.
Not only that it also sentenced a lot of scientists to death, imprisoned them,
tortured them etc. Just for proving that “the earth moves around sun”, Galileo,
Copernicus and a lot of scientists were brutally tortured by Church and the
popes. Let’s see some
proof in net ---
Rather the aim of the objector is now under question.
Decision: Jakir wasn’t wrong, rather
the objector did lie.
8)
Eighth Mistake: Jakir
says, “Church sentenced Galileo to death”
Ahmed said, “No, Church didn’t sentence Galileo to death,
rather he was house arrested”.
Analysis: Although it was said that Galileo
was sentenced to death, actually there is no proof that church sentenced
Galileo to death.
But, not only house-arrested him, but also it did tortured him a lot
these ways ---
a) As
soon as he gave the theory that, “The earth moves”, Church went against him and
forced him to stop spreading it
b) At
last Galileo was bound to admit that he won’t say any more that “ The earth
moves round the sun”, that’s the heliocentrism.
c) Pope 5th paul changed his writing and put that the
earth is static.
d) One of Galileo’s friend was
selected as pope Urban VIII in 1623. Then Galileo got the permission from his friend pope to write the
book again. But as soon as the book was published, the new pope also stopped
the publication of the book and kept it in prohibited books index.
e) By the way Galileo flee
away from Rome before.
f) He was ordered to come
Rome back for inquisition. He was sick and also knew the brutal process of
inquisition. So he was afraid and wished to answer through mail. Yet Church forced him to come,
otherwise he would have to go to jail.
g) 3 physicians stated that
Galileo’s health is not fit for travelling 200 km and go Rome. Church didn’t
pay hid and he was bound to go Rome.
h) The inquisition lasted
eight months, oh but no idea what the brutal processes they used in inquisition.
After 8 months torturing, he was given the following punishments
also ---
· His book was banned.
· He had to admit that he spoke wrong.
· He was house arrested till death.
· He was not allowed to be buried beside his father’s tomb.
· Pope didn’t allow proper funeral of Galileo.
· All these punishments were done by his friend pope Urban VIII.
Refferences ---
Decision:
Jakir
was wrong. Galileo wasn’t sentenced to
death.
9)
Ninth mistake: Jakir said, “Some scientists supported Darwin’s theory
when he published it”.
Objector said, “Not only when Darwin was alive , rather till a long time
after his death, most scientists did not accepted it”.
Analysis:
· Before Darwin published his theory, a scientist, named Alfred Rashel
Wales wrote a letter to him, expressing his wish to publish his writing,
“Natural selection” along with Darwin’s selection. That means he supported his
theory also. Proof --
· Darwin had 3 ther friends, who helped him many ways. They are ---
1) Thomas Huxley – a
biologist and anatomist – Known as the bulldog of Darwin for his deep support
and help in publishing it.
2) Charles Lyell - চার্লস
লীল – A geologist and lawyer.
3) Joseph Dalton Hooker - Botanists and an explorer – also a founder
of geographical botany.
Have a look at these wiki links about these scientists ---
So it’s not true that
scientists didn’t accept the theory at that time.
Decision: Jakir was right.
10)
Tenth mistake: Jakir
spelled, like Homonide.
Objector said, “no it will be Homonid”.
Analysis: It is neither Homonide nor
Homonid. Its Hominid. But when you go for pronunciation, they are all but
same. So why did the objector accuse him
for pronunciation? Different people spell words in different way of course.
It’s not a mistake at all.
Decision:
Jakir wasn’t wrong, rather the objector proved a bit enmity with
him.
11)
Eleventh mistake: Jakir
said, “ Hominids are of 4 types”.
Objector said, “ No, there are 14 types of hominids”.
Analysis:
Hominids are mainly
divided into 4 types. See reference
No comments:
Post a Comment