(3rd Part) Analysis & answer of
Dr.Zakir Naik's 25 mistake in 5 min
12)
Twelfth mistake: Jakir
says, ‘One of the Hominids is ‘Dosnopyticest”.
Ahmed said, “its rather “Australopithecus”.
Analysis:
Did you hear it really? Just see again and listen, Zakir just said Australopithecus
not Dosnopyticest. Its just a lie . See this part in video ---
Decision:
Nothing but a vague and fake complain against Zakir.
13)
Thirteenth mistake: Jakir
said, “Australopithecus died about 3.5
million years ago, which was an ICE AGE “.
The objector said, “There were no ice age 3.5 million years ago,
rather ice age was about 1.6 million to 10,000 years ago”.
Analysis:
There were at least five
major ice ages in earth till now. Australopithecus Africanas existed between 3 –
2 million years ago, then died. Last major ice age started about 2.58 million
years ago which is the time when Australopithecus Africanas died. So it’s absurd to say that 3.5 million years
ago is wrong and 3 million years is correct. Taking just that .5 million in
consideration. See the proof here ---
Decision: It’s not wrong; rather
Jakir was more correct than Ahmed, because ice age didn’t start at 1.6 million
years ago.
14) Fourteenth mistake: Jakir said, “Homo
sapiens died about 500000 years ago.
Ahmed said, “Homo sapiens means human beings. Jakir is
also a human but says that human died 500000 years ago”.
Analysis: One thing is true that by
the word homo sapiens, actually we mean human. But remember, homo sapiens is of
four types --
· Homo sapiens idaltu a
proposed subspecies (extinct) related to the modern human subspecies Homo
sapiens sapiens
· Homo sapiens
neanderthalensis an alternative to Homo
neanderthalsis that implies Neanderthal man
· Homo sapiens rhodesiensis an alternative nomenclature for Homo
rhodesiensis
· Homo sapiens sapiens subspecies that precisely
represents modern humans
Proof:
So, the word, “Homo sapiens died” doesn’t mean that human beings
died. The objector was a bit rude against zakir here. But Zakir should have said, actually which
subspecies he meant among these four homo sapiens.
Decision: Zakir Naik provided
incomplete information.
15)
Fifteenth mistake: Jakir
said, “Neanderthal
man died about 100 thousand to 40 thousand years ago”.
Objector Ahmed said, “ No, they died 30
thousand years ago and also Neanderthals
are not in the line of modern man”.
Analysis: Neanderthals are of course
in the line of modern man. Ahmed gave us false information. See proof here
---
But Neanderthals lived about 600 thousand to 30 thousand years ago. So
Jakir said 40 thousand years. Do you wanna think it to be a mistake ( speaking
40 thousand instead of 30 thousand ) ? Even recently about another Neanderthal
man’s fossil was discovered which is about 24 thousand years old.
Decision:
Neanderthals are under modern
man’s line, its true statement of Zakir but The year should not be 100 to 40
thousand , rather 30 thousand.
16)
Sixteenth mistake: Jakir
said, “ Then came the 4th stage, the cro-
magnon”.
Objector said, “ Cro- magnon is nothing but homo sapiens”.
Analysis: So what’s the difference?
Instead of homo sapiens, jakir used cro magnon , which is same. Where is the
mistake ?
Decision:
Jakir was correct.
17)
Seventeenth mistake: Jakir
said, “There
is no link between the stages”.
Ahmed said, “No, There are links”.
Analysis: Actually there is a lot of debate about these links. Changing from
just a little amoeba to human being needs billions of links which are really
time consuming to find. Also there are many links but not enough to prove the
whole change. May be scientists will need some hundreds to thousands years to
get the links and then sort it. May be not. But arguing about this issue is
worthless.
Decision: Both
are correct.
18)
Eighteenth mistake: Jakir
said, “Albert Georgie
invented vitamin C”.
Objector Ahmed said, “ Georgie didn’t invent it, rather
discovered it”.
Analysis:
How dishonest and mean is Mr. so called Ahmed to argue about invent
and discover. If you say “ I ate a bread
and a glass of juice”. Ahmed will say, you did wrong because you rather drank
the juice not eat . Amazing.
Decision: Its not a mistake rather
just slip of tongue, which we generally do in our day today life.
19)
Nineteenth mistake: Jakir said, “Georgie
wrote a book named Crazy ape n man”.
Ahmed said, “ No, It was Crazy ape”.
Analysis:
Difference
between Crazy ape n man aand Crazy ape ? What sort of ill mentality to argue
with such stupid things.
Decision: Jakir used incomplete
name.
20
Twentieth mistake: Jakir
said, “Scientist Rupert Albert gave a theory against Darwin”.
Ahmed said, “ There is no man named Rupert Albert”.
Analysis: Here also Jakir
misspelled. There are a lot of scientists who spoke against Darwin. He might
have used the wrong name here. He could use the following names instead who
wrote against Darwin
Another theory against Darwin’s theory , although nothing special
Decision:
Jakir misspelled.
21)
Twenty first mistake: Jakir
said, “Scientist
Frank Salisbury said, ‘its absurd to believe Darwin’s theory”.
Ahmed said, “There is no scientist named Salisbury”.
Analysis: Frank B. Salisbury was a
botanist, who really spoke against Darwin theory. See his name at 183 serial of 480 intellectuals,
who spoke against Darwin.
Have a look at Salisbury’s profile here
in wiki
The name of his book was “Doubts About the Modern Synthetic Theory of Evolution”
No comments:
Post a Comment